Review: Rogue Echo Rower – How Does It Stack Up Against the Concept2?

When it comes to rowing machines, the Rogue Echo Rower and Concept2 Rower are two of the most popular choices for CrossFitters and fitness enthusiasts alike. Known for their durability, smooth performance, and ability to withstand intense training, both machines have built a strong reputation in the fitness community.

But how does the Rogue Echo Rower really compare to the tried-and-true Concept2? Let’s break down the good, the bad, and how these two rowers stack up against each other.

The Good

1. Built Like a Tank

One of the standout features of the Rogue Echo Rower is its incredible build quality. Constructed from heavy-duty steel, it feels rock-solid even during the most intense rowing sessions. Unlike some rowers that tend to wobble or shift around, the Echo Rower stays firmly planted on the ground, thanks to its hefty weight of around 145 pounds.

By comparison, the Concept2 Model D weighs around 57 pounds, making it much lighter and more portable. While this makes the Concept2 easier to move, it doesn’t feel as stable as the Echo Rower, especially during all-out sprints.

2. Smooth and Powerful Air Resistance

The Rogue Echo Rower features a fan-based resistance system that provides a smooth and consistent stroke. The harder you pull, the more resistance you generate, mimicking the feel of rowing on water. The resistance is both powerful and responsive, making it great for both long endurance rows and short, powerful sprints.

The Concept2 Rower also uses air resistance and is known for its fluid, natural feel. While both rowers perform well in this department, the Echo Rower feels a bit more robust, giving a slightly heavier and more grounded experience.

3. Ergonomics and Comfort

The ergonomic handle of the Echo Rower is well-padded and comfortable to grip, even during long sessions. The adjustable footrests secure your feet well without causing discomfort, and the seat glides smoothly along the rail. The seat itself is firm yet comfortable, and the longer rail accommodates taller athletes, which is a nice touch.

While the Concept2’s seat is also comfortable, some users may find it slightly less padded than the Echo Rower. However, Concept2 does offer an aftermarket seat cushion for added comfort.

4. Storage and Portability

Despite its heavy frame, the Echo Rower folds up for easy storage, and the built-in wheels make it manageable to move around. The Concept2 Model D is more portable due to its lighter weight and quick-release frame lock, which allows for easy separation into two parts.

The Bad

1. Noise Level

Like most air rowers, the Echo Rower is loud. The fan generates significant noise during vigorous rowing, which might not be ideal for shared living spaces. The Concept2 is also noisy, but users report it being slightly quieter than the Echo, which could be a factor if sound is a concern.

2. Basic Performance Monitor

The PM5 monitor on the Concept2 is renowned for its accuracy and advanced features, including Bluetooth connectivity, heart rate monitoring, and various workout modes. In contrast, the Echo Rower’s monitor is basic, providing essential metrics like time, distance, calories, and strokes per minute. It lacks some of the advanced features and connectivity that the Concept2 offers, which might be a dealbreaker for tech-savvy users.

3. Heavier and Less Portable

While the heavy build of the Echo Rower makes it incredibly stable, it also makes it harder to move around. If you need to frequently reposition or store your rower, the lighter and more portable Concept2 might be a better option.

Which One Should You Buy?

Choosing between the Rogue Echo Rower and the Concept2 Model D comes down to your priorities:

• If you value stability, rugged construction, and smooth power during intense workouts, the Echo Rower is hard to beat. It’s built to last and can handle the toughest training sessions without budging.

• If you prefer a lighter, more portable machine with advanced tech features and a quieter performance, the Concept2 Model D is a tried-and-true option that has earned its place as a staple in gyms worldwide.

Final Verdict

The Rogue Echo Rower is an impressive machine that lives up to Rogue’s reputation for quality and durability. It’s ideal for CrossFit athletes and serious fitness enthusiasts who want a rock-solid, powerful rower that can take a beating. However, the basic monitor and higher noise level might make it less appealing to those who prefer more features and a quieter experience.

Meanwhile, the Concept2 Model D remains the gold standard for rowing machines, offering a smoother, quieter ride with more tech options and a lighter frame.